Just what Germany could have accomplished—had it been able to concentrate on just one front—became painfully clear in 1918. LEGENDARY U.S. General George S. Patton realized late in the war that the United States fought the wrong country. 1. The Germans probably wouldn’t have been able to enjoy their victory for long. The battle of the Atlantic, well on the way to being won in 1941, was almost lost in 1942 and 1943. To expect the United States to nuke another country without a declaration of war, and one that would be defacto a large trading partner is a little too far to to believe. Half of the Allied army in the west would have been gone so new man would have been needed to fill up the gap. If we look at how the war played out the Soviets faced 5/6ths of the German Army while the American army got slammed at the battle of the bulge while facing just a tiny fraction of the German army. With the Nazi victory in Europe, United States would have been left alone to fight the war on its … Even with everything noted above, Germany and its European partners could have still won the war were it not for Germany's declaration of war on the United States on December 11, 1941. My point is that Germany wouldn't have lost the war if the United States wouldn't have supported UK and France. In minimizing the value of the AEF on the battlefield they fail to analyze what its absence would have meant. If Imperial Germany won WW1. If Hitler had won, apart from Germany and the European front, the entire history of Asia and the Pacific would have changed dramatically as well. In any event, fortune, or rather misfortune, saved the world. Yes, but with a lot more casualties (especially on the side of the Russians). Central And South America. Did the Nazis have a real chance … Britain was America's enemy in the revolutionary war and in the war of 1812. Seriously, a lot of people here think that Germany and even A-H will come out stronger from the war. But the war that erupted across Europe in the summer of 1914 could hardly have been more senseless. Together with firms in Austria, France and the Netherlands, German energy companies are spending over $5 billion to build a Nord Stream 2 pipeline under the Baltic Sea. The US's importance in WW1 was small. If we had had to fight Nazi Germany one on one, we could not have stood up against Germany’s pressure, and we would have lost the war. Wilson believed that a "peace without victory" would help avoid future wars because since Germany got destroyed during WW1 and since they lost they had to pay reparations to the Allies and Wilson didn't want that. 101. The war would have gone as it did. 100% Upvoted. This could have been solved and handled in various ways, but as Germany was during this time in practice ruled by the military, the leadership used the tool they knew how to use: War. Many people say Germany could not win ww2 and many say Germany could win WW2. Up to three quarters of shipping lost during the war was because of the loss of the American 'safe zone' in the Western Atlantic - and particularly the second 'Happy Time' for the U-boats - the diversion of US Navy vessels to the Pacific, and the latter withdrawal of escort carriers to invade North Africa. The US faced both Japan and Germany (no longer allies) in two separate cold wars. Several historians have noted that both world wars should really be considered a single conflict with a long armistice in the middle. Hitler might have won WWII if he'd left Russia alone. Many people say Germany could not win ww2 and many say Germany could win WW2. Germany had the military potential to defeat France and likely force Britain to make peace, but with a Navy less than one-sixth the size of Britain’s, it had no means to even attack U.S. territory, let alone defeat it. Exactly They're over here … The truth is that the invasion took place when it was already clear that Germany was collapsing on the Eastern Front. No. The Allies (mainly Britain, France, US) won WW1 which happened from 1914-1919. The U.S. could easily … Up to three quarters of shipping lost during the war was because of the loss of the American 'safe zone' in the Western Atlantic - and particularly the second 'Happy Time' for the U-boats - the diversion of US Navy vessels to the Pacific, and the latter withdrawal of escort carriers to invade North Africa. Here are some actions that Germany might have taken to achieve their … In the final offensive the US forces lost only 100,000 men while the French lost 500,000 men. I am pretty sure that Germany could not have imposed terms similar to Versailles on Great Britain, i. e. stripping her of her navy. The Battle of Verdun. Eventually without America the Nazi's could even have defteated Russia, presuming that their war production could have kept up and their research not halted by American bombs. It is likely Britain and France could have won the war without US troops. By New Year's Day 1918, the British Army had been bled before Passchendaele, the French Army had suffered both defeat and mutiny from the Nivelle Offensive and Russia, then under Lenin, had … Going into the 2000s would have perhaps seen a Gorbachev-like Nazi leader, seeking better relations with the United States, and a Nazi version of perestroika. Even if the US had eventually done so, it would have been much later and the Germans would have bought themselves adequate time to confront their enemy. America would have done better if we joined the German's side, However President Woodrow Wilson was an anglophile, And he decided to let the British win WW1 so He sent the U. S. Army over there to help the the British. But they they may not have won the war without US supplies. Summer camps on the Plattsburg model were authorized for new officers, and the government was … lead to America getting involved in WW1. I'm sensing the American government would've been keen to to get that moment back. It was going to happen no matter what. I do have a plan by which the Germans could have won in 1940: depends on Dev doing ’16 again. • March 1917 Allies not able to break German lines-Battles of Arras and Ypres. The allies were also developing the tactics needed to win battles. If this viewpoint is valid, then the official outcome of the first phase … This likely would have happened within a year or two according to figures shown in the work. Along with the Americans entering the war I also feel as though the German U-boats and submarines were unjust and unfair. What follows here is my take on this subject, based not only on standard history books, but on information gathered from formerly classified intelligence from U.S., German, and Soviet files, much of it published in excellent books. Soviet resistance was in some ways the most surprising outcome. Rommel believed Germany would have won World War ii —if it had invaded the Middle East first! Let's suppose that Central Powers win 1st World war in 1916. Hulton Archive/Getty Images. The fabric of German society was fraying, America had entered the war, the army was tired, replacements were no longer possible. share. World War 2: what would have happened if in 1941, Third Reich Germany and Soviet Union had fought one on one, without any foreign help? Very little change here from what we know, except that Nazi Germany has occupied Cuba to have a western hemisphere base of operations. In the thirties to re arm. How Germany Could Have Won World War I. The Army was to double in size to 11,300 officers and 208,000 men, with no reserves, and a National Guard that would be enlarged in five years to 440,000 men. The United States of America entered the war after the Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor in Hawaii in 1941, and marked the beginning of the Pacific front of the war and quickly the war stretched from Europe to Pacific and into Asia as well. In the late 1950s, the US and Germany developed nuclear weapons with long-range bombardiers. This video is about how the allies could not have won WWII without the help of America. Eventually they would have won, but it may have taken one or two more years or so. Example – his hesitation at Dunkirk. Herewith, my list of five ways Imperial Japan could have offset the resource disparity: Don't fight land and sea wars simultaneously. A Victorious Germany in WWI Would Have Prevented the Nazis—But It May Have Been Nearly as Bad. 10 comments. The Germans never did though. A Victorious Germany in WWI Would Have Prevented the Nazis—But It May Have Been Nearly as Bad. And as you can imagine, it is NOT a pretty picture for anyone. Alsace-Lorraine have many natural defenses so a push through there would be difficult for the french. Central And South America. Close. You don’t find much in Hitler’s writings about Britain compared to other countries. 4, issues 17-20), Captain America awakens from suspended animation in 1964 to find that - due to a temporal anomaly - Nazi Germany has won WWII and conquered much of the world, including the United States. David Cameron visits the graves of first world war soldiers in Zonnebeke, Belgium. Archived. hide. unrestricted submarine warfare. Why did Germany declare war on America? 06-18-2008, 12:55 PM AONE : Location: Orlando. This video is about how the allies could not have won WWII without the help of America. Argonne Offensive (1918) one of the costliest military campaigns in American history. By the end of the war, millions of civilians across Germany and Austria-Hungary had starved to death, meanwhile the French and British had a steady supply of food coming in … Who would have won? The country would have imposed peace on the defeated allies at the treaty of Potsdam, and it would not have had the reparations and grievances that were generally inflicted by France and Versailles. Hitler might have won WWII if he'd left Russia alone. Germany had the military potential to defeat France and likely force Britain to make peace, but with a Navy less than one-sixth the size of Britain’s, it had no means to even attack U.S. territory, let alone defeat it. The Wall Street crash and Depression. ... Germany could have found diplomatic means to have fought against Russia alone without war with France, or vice-versa. Several historians agree that although Germany and the US were unofficially at war, the Americans may not have wanted to … Who would have won World War 1 if the US hadn't intervened? The battle of the Atlantic, well on the way to being won in 1941, was almost lost in 1942 and 1943. If we had had to fight Nazi Germany one on one, we could not have stood up against Germany’s pressure, and we would have lost the war. Example – his hesitation at Dunkirk. No. ... Could the Allies have won WW1 without the US? 06-18-2008, 12:55 PM AONE : Location: Orlando. What follows here is my take on this subject, based not only on standard history books, but on information gathered from formerly classified intelligence from U.S., German, and Soviet files, much of it published in excellent books. Kdude, you need read more closely what I wrote. Could Germany have won the war with the entrance of the United States? 1. But they they may not have won the war without US supplies. Nikita Khrushchev offered the same opinion. Yes, Germany Could Have Won World War I. How Nazi Germany Could Have Won World War II: An Alliance with Russia? Top 10 Weapons That Could Have Lost Us The War. In the 2003-2004 Captain America story arc Cap Lives (Captain America Vol. Yes, Germany Could Have Won World War I. Here are some actions that Germany might have taken to achieve their … It must be baldly stated: Germany would have won World War I had the U.S. Army not intervened in France in 1918. Others factors to bear in mind were that Germany borrowed heavily from the U.S. Who would have won World War 1 if the US hadn't intervened? If Germany had exercised caution in this regard, there is a chance that the US would not have formally declared war on Germany. In this video we discuss whether this is a myth or not. WW1 was a bit different than WW2 as the Germans weren't exactly evil like the Nazi's were. In the thirties to re arm. How Germany Could Have Won World War I. And US troops were involved, albeit against orders, and under the command of an Australian General. Of course, the best way for Germany to have won World War II was for it to have avoided fighting Britain, France, and the United States of America altogether. But without the Allies in his back, Hitler would have sent all his forces to the East and the Russians would have had a hard time stopping him. In a way, this is a more interesting hypothesis than the more commonly asked question about what the world would be like if the Germans had won World War II. So Germany and Austria-Hungary could have won a short war, but the longer the war be dragged out, the more and more the weight of the Entente's vast colonies' resources and manpower would crush the Central Powers. How would the war have ended if America had not intervened? If Germany had won WW1 Speculative History: … The US was supplying the allies with large amounts of equipment and resources. hide. If Hitler had won, apart from Germany and the European front, the entire history of Asia and the Pacific would have changed dramatically as well. Who won World War 1? 29 January, 2017. Posted by 8 years ago. A lot of historic material exists to support various theories about how the Germans and the Japanese could have won World War II. Without the Russian Front, Germany would have turned the beaches of Europe into an impenetrable fortress. by STL Mo. I'm sensing the American government would've been keen to to get that moment back. It is likely Britain and France could have won the war without US troops. WW1 was won by the British and the French, WW2 was won by all allies, but if it wasn’t for the British fighting alone for 3 years keeping Hitler/Germany busy the war would have had a different outcome as all their efforts would have been against Russia and America wouldn’t have had anywhere to build their forces or the British to train them as they did. Six weeks later, France surrendered. A lot of historic material exists to support various theories about how the Germans and the Japanese could have won World War II. But it boggles the mind to imagine what might have happened if Hitler didn’t go to war in 1939, but waited several more years. Just what Germany could have accomplished—had it been able to concentrate on just one front—became painfully clear in 1918. The war would have gone as it did. If Germany had won on the Western Front, it would have acquired some French territory and maybe Belgium. In this video we discuss whether this is a myth or not. ... instead of the tools that won the war for the Nazis. ‘At least we can see that the outcome mattered. Last edited by Dick Armey; Today at 01:50 PM.. +8 6 hrs ago '14 #59: westsidedon 9 K 698. Who knows? 16. Just steaming parallel to them at full speed would sink them. If US internal policy had managed to stop this happening then Germany would not have been in a state where Hitler could have taken power.
Safest Place In Italy To Live, Gel Nail Art Designs For Short Nails, Best Balance Druid Soulbind Night Fae, Expedia Revenue By Country, Langley Steinert Net Worth, St Louis Cardinals Giveaways June 2021, Phipps Houses Low Income Apartments, Bounce House Rental Norfolk Ne, Town Of Medley Finance Department, Walmart Ceaco Puzzles,